Health care becomes flashpoint in Minnesota governor’s race

Health care has emerged as the most contentious issue in the Minnesota’s governor’s race, as both candidates grapple with the bedeviling details of a system that is both worrying to families and phenomenally expensive to taxpayers.

Republican nominee Jeff Johnson and U.S. Rep. Tim Walz both say that all Minnesotans — even those with pre-existing conditions — should have access to affordable health care.

That’s where the agreement ends. A fiery exchange at a debate in Willmar on Tuesday drove home the divide, and Johnson also criticized Walz over health care earlier in the day at a news conference.

Johnson, a Hennepin County commissioner, has been hitting Walz for favoring what he calls a “single payer” health care plan.

“We have to understand what single payer means,” Johnson said. “We all lose our insurance and are forced on to one government plan.”

Single payer advocates use Medicare — the government insurance program for Americans 65 and older — as an example of how socialized insurance can cover all Americans at lower cost than the current private system.

Johnson cites Walz’s answer to a questionnaire from a progressive group: “We also recognize that expanding Minnesota’s public option is just a start, ultimately, we need to enact a single-payer system, and as Governor I will fight to put us on a path toward single-payer health care.”

In a recent interview, Walz cited statistics showing Americans spend twice as much for health care as the rest of the industrialized world, often for inferior results. He said he views Medicare access for all Americans as an inevitability, but on a national, not a state level.

Asked if he would make it a priority at the state level, Walz said, “This is a difficult one. California tried to do it. Vermont tried to do it.” Both gave up on the effort.

For the moment, Walz is proposing a plan that would mimic one offered by DFL Gov. Mark Dayton, which would allow all Minnesotans to buy into the public health insurance program that is currently reserved for the working poor called MinnesotaCare, giving all residents a public insurance option.

Johnson attacked the proposal this week by arguing that because MinnesotaCare pays lower reimbursement rates than private insurance, rural hospitals and health clinic could face financial ruin if thousands of Minnesotans are using the new government insurance option. He cited the Minnesota Hospital Association, which opposed Dayton’s MinnesotaCare buy-in proposal.

Wendy Burt, vice president of the hospital association, said the group is bipartisan, does not endorse and has made no determination about Walz’s plan. Burt said the hospital group has made no claims about whether hospitals would close if more people were enrolled in MinnesotaCare. “We don’t know that. We haven’t said that,” she said.

(The hospital association comprises 142 institutions, nearly all of them nonprofit. Some are owned by insurance companies which would be in direction competition with the expanded MinnesotaCare.)

While the hospitals oppose the Dayton MinnesotaCare buy-in, they also oppose aspects of Johnson’s plan.

Johnson said he wants to give consumers more choices, including buying so-called “skinny” health insurance plans, which are less expensive but do not offer comprehensive health benefits.

Walz, who voted for the Affordable Care Act and then voted dozens of times against repealing it, pointed out a potential problem with this approach during the Tuesday debate: “Let’s say I’m 28. You decide I’m healthy. I’m fine. You don’t buy into the (insurance) system. The pool shrinks. The pool shrinks. The pool shrinks. Rates go up.”

In other words, if younger, healthier customers opt-out of comprehensive health coverage, the remaining older, sicker customers will have to pay significantly more to account for higher risk.

Burt said the hospital association is also opposed to this idea because it could hurt bottom lines: “If you’re 27 and you get in a motorcycle accident and you don’t have (comprehensive) coverage, guess who pays for that health care? The hospitals.”

The Affordable Care Act required individuals to have comprehensive coverage, a mandate that Congress repealed in 2017. But the law also forced insurers to take on all customers, even high risk customers with pre-existing conditions.

Johnson said he would like to see Minnesota return to a system in place before the Affordable Care Act, in which people with pre-existing conditions who could not get coverage anywhere else could enroll in a program called the Minnesota Comprehensive Health Association (MCHA). The government-chartered nonprofit provided coverage to those who couldn’t get private market coverage. Insurance companies and policyholders funded it, but premiums were higher than market rates. MCHA needed three cash infusions just to stay afloat.

Even with help from the taxpayers, enrollment was steadily declining as premiums increased, and when it closed there were only 20,000 Minnesotans covered.

Johnson and Walz differ on another key state health care issue. A tax on health care providers that’s used to pay for health care programs is set to expire at the end of 2019. Walz wants to extend it. Johnson wants it to end on schedule. It currently brings in $700 million per year and is funding insurance for low, middle and even upper-income Minnesotans in the individual market. In 2017-18, for instance, the Legislature spent $543 million to pay off insurance companies’ most expensive claims, which helped stabilize the market and reduce rates this year.

Much of the health care debate between Walz and Johnson is actually a return to a contentious argument that has roiled American politics for a decade: the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare.

During the debate Tuesday, Walz said that since its passage, the number of Minnesotans in Kandiyohi County without insurance dropped by half. Statewide, the number of Minnesotans without insurance before Obamacare was 8.2 percent. It dropped to 4.1 percent in 2015, but last year jumped back up to 6.3 percent.

Johnson said since Obamacare rolled out, Minnesota has been mired in mediocrity.

“We kind of got sucked down to the same level as everybody else and now we don’t do it better than everybody else anymore,” Johnson said.

Data from the federal government, however, indicates that Minnesota continues to lead the nation in health statistics, including life expectancy and access to health care.

rn//Load jQuery library using plain JavaScriptrn(function(){rn var newscript = document.createElement(‘script’);rn newscript.type = ‘text/javascript’;rn newscript.async = true;rn newscript.src = ‘https://code.jquery.com/jquery-3.1.0.min.js’;rn (document.getElementsByTagName(‘head’)[0]||document.getElementsByTagName(‘body’)[0]).appendChild(newscript);rnvar newscript2 = document.createElement(‘script’);rn newscript2.type = ‘text/javascript’;rn newscript2.async = true;rn newscript2.src = ‘https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/js-cookie/2.1.3/js.cookie.min.js’;rn (document.getElementsByTagName(‘head’)[0]||document.getElementsByTagName(‘body’)[0]).appendChild(newscript2);rn})();rn/********TEST CODE for METER SNOW PLOW ANALYTiCS*******************/rnvar meter = {};rn$(document).ready(function(){rn // console.log(“this loads well”);rn $(‘.js-optimizely-click-goal’).click(function(){rn // console.log(this);rn meter[‘type’] = $(“input[name=’offer’]”).val();rn if(meter[‘type’] = 131){meter[‘type’] = “Premium Digital Access”;}rn else if(meter[‘type’] = 130){meter[‘type’] = “Sunday Print + Digital”;}rn else if(meter[‘type’] = 129){meter[‘type’] = “7-Day Print + Digital”;}rn else if(meter[‘type’] = 128){meter[‘type’] = “Sunday Print”;}rn meter[‘date’] = new Date().toLocaleString();rn // console.log(meter[‘type’]);rn // console.log(meter[‘date’]);rn var json_meter_cookie = JSON.stringify(meter);rn Cookies.set(‘meter_sign_up’, json_meter_cookie); rn rn });rn});rn/************************************************************************/rn // FACEBOOK TRACKING PIXEL #1rn !function(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)rn {if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=function(){n.callMethod?rn n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments)};rn if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;n.push=n;n.loaded=!0;n.version=’2.0′;rn n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!0;rn t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];rn s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)}(window,document,’script’,rn ‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);rn fbq(‘init’, ‘590074241155998’); rn fbq(‘track’, ‘ViewContent’);rn rnrn{% endblock %}”},”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/limit-signup-optimizely/start”},{“id”:”limit-signup”,”count”:12,”action”:”ignore”,”mute”:true,”action_config”:{“template”:”{% extends “grid” %}rnrn{% block heading_text %}Youu2019ve read your 10 free articles for this 30 day period. Sign up now for local coverage you wonu2019t find anywhere else, special sections and your favorite columnists. StarTribune puts Minnesota and the world right at your fingertips. {% endblock %}rnrn{% block last %}rn{{ parent() }}rn{# limit Krux pixel from https://www.squishlist.com/strib/customshop/328/ #}rnrnrn{% endblock %}”},”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/limit-signup/start”},{“id”:”PDA991499opt”,”count”:9,”action”:”ignore”,”mute”:false,”action_config”:false,”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/PDA991499opt/start”},{“id”:”limit”,”count”:8,”action”:”inject”,”mute”:true,”action_config”:{“template”:”

rnrnrnrn

rn

rn

rn rn

rn t

rn SUBSCRIBErn Already a subscriber? Log in.rn

rn

All Star Tribune readers without a Digital Access subscription are given a limited number of complimentary articles every 30 days. Once the article limit is reached we ask readers to purchase a subscription including Digital Access to continue reading. Digital Access is included in all multi-day paper home delivery, Sunday + Digital, and Premium Digital Access subscriptions. After the 1 month Premium Digital Access introductory period you will be charged at a rate of $14.99 per month. You can see all subscription options or login to an existing subscription herern

rn rn

rn

rn

rn

rn

rn”},”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/limit/start”},{“id”:”nag”,”count”:7,”action”:”lightbox”,”mute”:true,”action_config”:{“height”:””,”width”:”630px”,”redirect_on_close”:””,”template”:”{% extends “shell” %}rnrn{% block substyles %}rn

rn{% endblock %}rnrn{% block page %}rn{#rnrn{{ limit – count – 1 }}rnrn{{ form.flow_form_open({nextAction: ‘firstSlide’}, null, null, ‘_top’) }}rn {{ form.btn(‘Save Now’) }}rn{{ form.flow_form_close() }}rnrn

rnrnrnu2022 rnrnrnrn#}rn

rn

rn

You have {{ limit – count – 1 }} articles left

rn

rn rn u00a0u00a0u2022u00a0u00a0rn rn

rn

rn

rn

rn Save More Todayrn

Over 70% off!

rn

rn

rn

rn

99u00a2 for first 4 weeks

rn {{ form.flow_form_open({nextAction: ‘firstSlide’}, null, null, ‘_top’) }}rn {{ form.button(‘Save Now’, ‘btn nag-btn’) }}rn {{ form.flow_form_close() }}rn

rn

rn{% endblock %}rnrn{% block last %}rn{{ parent() }}rnrn{% endblock %}”},”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/nag/start”},{“id”:”x”,”count”:4,”action”:”ignore”,”mute”:true,”action_config”:false,”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/x/start”},{“id”:”multi-start”,”count”:3,”action”:”fly_in”,”mute”:true,”action_config”:{“location”:”bottom_left”,”slide_direction”:”bottom”,”group_id”:””,”display_delay”:”0″,”collapse_delay”:”10″,”template”:”

rn

rn

rn

rn u00d7rn

rn

rn

From just

rn

$3.79 99u00a2 a week

rn Save nowrn

rn

rn

“},”start”:”https://users.startribune.com/placement/1/environment/3/multi-start/start”}]};


Source